Winter Baseball Obsession

H2H vs Roto

I'm in, and I'm voting ROTO

H2H, although I am open to other option.

One factor that I think needs to be considered, some teams do approach this as a tangible, regular league. For that reason alone, I do think we should stick with just these two options. A draft alone league (zero transactions) does have appeal to me, but I worry about our ability to find 20 other managers who would be up for that kind of arrangement. There are two big draws about this league for me: the early Xmas timeline of the draft and the amount of depth necessary to complete a full roster with 20 teams. If we miss out on those, then I question what I get out of this league.

I am so for roto. Head to head was so bad that I am considering not being part of the league if that is the case....and I have others that feel the same way.

Scrantonicity wrote:H2H, although I am open to other option.

One factor that I think needs to be considered, some teams do approach this as a tangible, regular league. For that reason alone, I do think we should stick with just these two options. A draft alone league (zero transactions) does have appeal to me, but I worry about our ability to find 20 other managers who would be up for that kind of arrangement. There are two big draws about this league for me: the early Xmas timeline of the draft and the amount of depth necessary to complete a full roster with 20 teams. If we miss out on those, then I question what I get out of this league.

The zero transaction league is awful. I played in one of those and everyone lost interest at the end of April.

Let's do roto. See message on main board. Sign up and start your research.

In. Roto.

Bump on this thread...Not sure if this is a fully resolved topic yet, but Id just like to say I really enjoyed H2H last year and not really sure why it needs to be changed, however, if the masses decide roto is the way to go, so be it. With that said, can I propose we keep the weekly lineups from last season??? I enjoyed the strategy of setting a weekly lineup, and it makes the league less labor intensive, and something we all dont have to be constantly worrying about... Just my two cents on the matter.

ucancallmedavis wrote:Bump on this thread...Not sure if this is a fully resolved topic yet, but Id just like to say I really enjoyed H2H last year and not really sure why it needs to be changed, however, if the masses decide roto is the way to go, so be it. With that said, can I propose we keep the weekly lineups from last season??? I enjoyed the strategy of setting a weekly lineup, and it makes the league less labor intensive, and something we all dont have to be constantly worrying about... Just my two cents on the matter.

We already decided to go with roto and weekly lineup selections. Opening this thread to discussion after it has been decided and we are deep into the draft is just trolling. It would completely change strategies if it were h2h. Let's leave this thread to die in dignity.

Pocket full of Posey wrote:

ucancallmedavis wrote:Bump on this thread...Not sure if this is a fully resolved topic yet, but Id just like to say I really enjoyed H2H last year and not really sure why it needs to be changed, however, if the masses decide roto is the way to go, so be it. With that said, can I propose we keep the weekly lineups from last season??? I enjoyed the strategy of setting a weekly lineup, and it makes the league less labor intensive, and something we all dont have to be constantly worrying about... Just my two cents on the matter.

We already decided to go with roto and weekly lineup selections. Opening this thread to discussion after it has been decided and we are deep into the draft is just trolling. It would completely change strategies if it were h2h. Let's leave this thread to die in dignity.

Oh cool, thanks for not being a dick about it.

PS-go fuck yourself.

ucancallmedavis wrote:

Pocket full of Posey wrote:

ucancallmedavis wrote:Bump on this thread...Not sure if this is a fully resolved topic yet, but Id just like to say I really enjoyed H2H last year and not really sure why it needs to be changed, however, if the masses decide roto is the way to go, so be it. With that said, can I propose we keep the weekly lineups from last season??? I enjoyed the strategy of setting a weekly lineup, and it makes the league less labor intensive, and something we all dont have to be constantly worrying about... Just my two cents on the matter.

We already decided to go with roto and weekly lineup selections. Opening this thread to discussion after it has been decided and we are deep into the draft is just trolling. It would completely change strategies if it were h2h. Let's leave this thread to die in dignity.

Oh cool, thanks for not being a dick about it.

PS-go fuck yourself.

Who needs spring training? We're already in midseason form!

ucancallmedavis wrote:

Pocket full of Posey wrote:

ucancallmedavis wrote:Bump on this thread...Not sure if this is a fully resolved topic yet, but Id just like to say I really enjoyed H2H last year and not really sure why it needs to be changed, however, if the masses decide roto is the way to go, so be it. With that said, can I propose we keep the weekly lineups from last season??? I enjoyed the strategy of setting a weekly lineup, and it makes the league less labor intensive, and something we all dont have to be constantly worrying about... Just my two cents on the matter.

We already decided to go with roto and weekly lineup selections. Opening this thread to discussion after it has been decided and we are deep into the draft is just trolling. It would completely change strategies if it were h2h. Let's leave this thread to die in dignity.

Oh cool, thanks for not being a dick about it.

PS-go fuck yourself.

Not being a dick about it. Just saying it was already decided. No reason to bring up something that was already set in place 2 weeks ago.

So, go look for another outfielder, offer some bogus trades, and clean the sand out of your vagina. Sounds like you really need it.